An Australian customer has gone into administration. Can an overseas supplier get its goods back?
- Published
- Law stated as at
Key points
- Whatever the contract says about who owns the goods, the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (‘PPSA’) treats a retention of title clause as a security interest. It applies to goods in Australia even if the supply contract is governed by a foreign law.
- If the interest is not perfected when the administrator is appointed, it passes to the customer. Perfection means completing the steps, usually registration, that protect the interest. The supplier is then left with an unsecured claim for the price, alongside the customer’s other unsecured creditors.
- A registration fails if a search against the right details (for most companies, the Australian Company Number) would not find it. It also fails if it was made more than 20 business days after the supply agreement came into force and within six months before the administrator’s appointment, unless a special 56-day period for some foreign-law contracts applies, or a court such as the Federal Court or a state or territory Supreme Court extends the time.
- A purchase money security interest (‘PMSI’) secures the price of the goods supplied. A registration that identifies the interest as a PMSI, and is in place before the customer obtains possession of the stock, ranks ahead of a lender’s general security over that stock.
- Even a registered supplier cannot take the goods back during the administration without the administrator’s written consent or the court’s permission (leave). If the administrator sells them, the supplier is paid from the net sale proceeds, in the order the PPSA sets and only as far as they go.
Suppose a supplier sells goods to Australia from overseas, and its Australian customer has gone into voluntary administration. In a voluntary administration, an independent insolvency practitioner, the administrator, takes control of a company in financial difficulty and works out whether it can be saved. The administrator’s first notice has arrived, the customer owes the supplier for three shipments, and pallets of the supplier’s goods are still in the customer’s warehouse. Every invoice carries retention of title terms, which say that the supplier owns the goods until it is paid.
Those terms now protect the supplier only if, when the administrator was appointed, its interest was already registered on the PPSR, correctly and in time. The PPSR is Australia’s national online register on which suppliers and lenders record their rights over goods and other property that secure payment. Without such a registration, the supplier’s interest in the goods passed to the customer at the appointment. The supplier is left with an unsecured claim for the price, which is not backed by any right to particular property.1 Even with one, the supplier cannot simply collect the goods, although it has a claim to them or to what they sell for.
Does our retention of title clause still protect us?
A retention of title clause still protects a supplier only if, when the administrator was appointed, the supplier’s interest was perfected and had been registered in time. Perfection is the PPSA’s term for the steps, usually registration, that protect the supplier’s interest if the customer becomes insolvent, meaning unable to pay its debts. The PPSA calls the supplier’s interest a security interest, meaning a right over the goods that secures payment. It treats a sale on retention of title terms that way whatever the contract says about who owns the goods.2 In the PPSA’s terms, the supplier is the secured party, and the customer is the grantor, the party that gives the security.
In practice, for goods already in the customer’s warehouse, perfection means an effective registration, because the supplier no longer has possession.3 The terms must also be in writing, signed or accepted by the customer, and must describe the goods. Without terms of that kind, the interest cannot be enforced against third parties, such as the customer’s other creditors, so it is not perfected even if it is registered.4
An interest that is unperfected at the appointment vests in the customer immediately before the administrator is appointed, which means the customer then holds the goods free of it.5 In the ordinary case, perfection is tested at the appointment itself, the moment the administration begins.6 So registering afterwards comes too late for goods already supplied. A registration made before the appointment can also come too late, as explained below.
Does the PPSA apply if our supply contract is governed by a foreign law?
The PPSA applies to goods in Australia even if the supply contract is governed by a foreign law, because it applies to a security interest in goods located in Australia.7 The law of the place where the goods are at the relevant time decides whether the interest was perfected, and what follows if it was not. Sometimes, when the supplier’s interest took effect, it was reasonable to believe that the goods would be moved to Australia. Australian law then governs the interest once the goods are in Australia, from the time the interest took effect. Business goods of a kind normally used in more than one country, such as shipping containers, are governed instead by the law of the country where the customer is located (for a company, where it is incorporated) when the interest takes effect.8
So for stock in an Australian warehouse when the administrator is appointed, Australian law decides whether the supplier’s interest survives, whatever law the supply contract chooses. The chosen law still governs the parties’ contractual obligations, such as the price and the payment terms.9 In practice, a clause that works under the supplier’s home law does not stand in for a PPSR registration. Questions of foreign law itself, such as a guarantee from the customer’s parent company overseas, are for a lawyer qualified in that country.
Which goods can a PPSR registration cover?
A PPSR registration can cover any goods, meaning tangible property such as stock, raw materials, machinery and vehicles.10 Each registration describes one class of collateral, the term for the property secured. Most goods supplied to a business fall in the class called ‘other goods’. Motor vehicles, watercraft and aircraft each have a class of their own. So a supplier of both trucks and spare parts needs two registrations: one in the motor vehicles class for the trucks, and one in the other goods class for the parts.11
In an administration, what the supplier can claim depends on what has happened to the goods since delivery:
- Goods still in the customer’s possession, and identifiable as the supplier’s, are covered by a registration in the right class. These are the goods the supplier can ask to collect.
- Goods already sold in the ordinary course of the customer’s business of selling goods of that kind are generally lost, because the buyer takes them free of the supplier’s interest. The interest then attaches to the proceeds, meaning what the customer received for them, so far as those can still be identified or traced. A registration over the goods also protects proceeds received as money, such as a payment into the customer’s bank account. A debt that the customer’s own buyer still owes is, in general, protected only if the registration also states that it covers proceeds.12
- Goods processed or mixed into a product so that they lose their identity, such as raw materials used in manufacturing, remain subject to the supplier’s interest, which continues in the product. The supplier’s priority over another security interest in that product is limited to the value of its goods on the day they became part of the product.13
- Goods installed in other goods, such as an engine fitted to a machine, generally remain subject to the supplier’s interest. The rule differs where both items are of a kind that may be registered by serial number, such as motor vehicles.14
- Goods attached to land, such as benchtops installed in a house, are fixtures, to which the PPSA does not apply.15 In practice, getting them back can be difficult.
Whatever kind of goods the supplier claims, the rules below on registration and on the administration apply to them.
Why do PPSR registrations fail?
Two registration problems can cost the supplier its claim to the goods. A third can cost it priority, meaning its place in the order in which secured creditors are paid.
Was the registration made against the right details?
For a customer company with an Australian Company Number (‘ACN’), the registration must be made against the ACN. The exception is a company that is the trustee of a trust with an Australian Business Number (‘ABN’). It is registered against the trust’s ABN, unless the trust is a registered managed investment scheme, a kind of pooled investment fund. A company that runs such a scheme is registered against the scheme’s Australian Registered Scheme Number (‘ARSN’).16 A registration is ineffective, and so does not perfect the interest, if a search of the register against the customer’s correct details would not find it.17
A registration against the ABN of a company that is not a trustee is ineffective for that reason, even where the ABN contains the ACN. In Re OneSteel Manufacturing Pty Ltd (admins apptd), a 2017 decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, a finance company had leased a crushing plant to a company that operated a mine. Brereton J held that the finance company’s registrations, made against the mining company’s ABN, were ineffective. Because the registrations were ineffective, the finance company, which had funded the plant at a cost of about $23.3 million, lost its interest in the plant to the mining company when administrators were appointed.18 In practice, a registration against the trading name on the purchase order is at the same risk.
Was the registration made in time?
A registration made more than 20 business days after the security agreement came into force, and within six months before the appointment, does not save the interest, which still vests in the customer. If the administrator is appointed before those 20 business days end, the registration must be in place before the appointment. The rule applies to an interest that, at the appointment, is enforceable against third parties and perfected by registration alone, as a supplier’s interest in delivered goods usually is.19
For a supplier, the security agreement is usually the supply contract that contains the retention of title terms. If that contract came into force under a foreign law, the registration deadline can be later. Where the interest first became enforceable against third parties under Australian law within the six months before the appointment, the supplier has 56 days from that point to register. That period can end later than the 20 business days. Either way, the registration must be made before the appointment.20
Even so, on the supplier’s application, a court with power under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), such as the Federal Court or a state or territory Supreme Court, may allow a later time for registration. It may do so if the failure to register in time was accidental, due to inadvertence or another sufficient cause, or would not prejudice creditors or shareholders, or if relief is otherwise just and equitable.21 However, the court’s power helps only an interest that was perfected at the appointment. In the OneSteel case, a fresh registration against the ACN after the appointment therefore had no effect.22
Some suppliers sell on account, under standing terms that cover many orders. For them, the Corporations Act does not say whether the agreement ‘came into force’ when the customer opened a trade account with the supplier or when each order was placed.23 In practice, registering within 20 business days after the account terms are agreed avoids the question.
Was the registration stated to be a purchase money interest?
A seller’s interest is a PMSI to the extent it secures the price of the goods.24 A registration that does not say it is a PMSI does not lose the goods in the administration. What the statement decides is who ranks first when a bank also holds security over all the customer’s assets.
For stock the customer holds to sell or to use as materials, a PMSI ranks ahead of a lender’s general security over that stock, even one registered earlier. To obtain this priority, the supplier’s registration must say that the interest is a PMSI and must already be in place when the customer obtains possession of the stock.25 For goods the customer buys to use, such as a machine, the supplier can obtain the same priority by registering the PMSI, marked as such, within 15 business days after the customer obtains possession. Goods shipped by a common carrier, such as a shipping line, are not yet in the customer’s possession. Possession comes when the customer, or someone at its request, obtains the goods or a document of title to them, such as a bill of lading, whichever comes first.26 Otherwise, registered interests generally rank in the order in which they were registered, so a bank that registered its general security first ranks ahead of the supplier.27
Which registrations survive, and how do they rank?
The table brings together the rules explained above. It shows, for each kind of registration at the appointment, whether the supplier keeps its claim to the goods and whether it ranks ahead of a bank with security over all the customer’s assets.
| The supplier’s registration at the appointment | Does the supplier keep its claim to the goods?28 | Does the supplier rank ahead of the bank? |
|---|---|---|
| None | No, the interest passes to the customer | Not relevant |
| Against the wrong details | No, if a search against the right details would not find it | Not relevant |
| More than 20 business days after the contract came into force (and outside any 56-day period for a foreign-law contract), and within six months before the appointment | No, unless a court extends the time | Not relevant |
| In time and against the right details, but not as a purchase money interest | Yes | Only if the supplier registered first |
| In time, against the right details and as a purchase money interest, but for stock only after the customer obtained possession of it | Yes | Only if the supplier registered first |
| In time, against the right details and as a purchase money interest: for stock, before the customer obtained possession of it; for goods the customer uses, within 15 business days after it obtained possession | Yes | Yes |
Can we enter the warehouse and take the goods back?
A supplier cannot take the goods back while the administration lasts, unless the administrator agrees in writing or the court gives its permission, called leave. The rule covers any owner of goods in the customer’s possession, including a supplier with a PPSA interest: the owner cannot take the goods back, and the secured party cannot enforce its security interest.29
For the purposes of the administration rules, the goods count as the customer’s property, so the administrator can deal with them, within limits.30 The administrator may sell them only in the ordinary course of the customer’s business, with the supplier’s written consent, or with the court’s leave. A demand for their return does not by itself stop sales in the ordinary course of business.31
A supplier that fears a sale can ask the court to direct the administrator not to proceed. However, the court may do so only if it is not satisfied that arrangements have been made to protect the supplier’s interests adequately.32
If the administrator sells goods subject to a perfected retention of title interest, the sale ends the supplier’s interest in them, and the supplier is paid, if at all, from the proceeds. The administrator must act reasonably in making the sale. The net proceeds then go in the order the PPSA sets for a secured party enforcing its interest. Higher-ranking interests that are not security interests come first, then the reasonable costs of enforcement, then higher-ranking security interests. The supplier’s secured debt follows, then lower-ranking interests, and only then the customer.33
How does a supplier vote at the creditors’ meetings?
A supplier can vote at a creditors’ meeting only if its debt has been admitted, or if it has lodged particulars of the debt. It lodges them with the person presiding at the meeting or with the person named in the meeting notice. If a formal proof of the debt is required, the supplier lodges that instead.34
At the second creditors’ meeting, which decides the company’s future, the creditors choose among three outcomes: a deed of company arrangement, ending the administration, or winding up the company, meaning closing it down.35 A deed of company arrangement is a binding agreement between the company and its creditors on how its debts will be dealt with. Such a deed does not stop a supplier with a perfected interest from enforcing that interest, unless the supplier voted for the deed and the deed provides otherwise, or the court orders otherwise.36
What should a supplier do in the first week of a customer’s administration?
- Search the PPSR against the customer’s ACN (for a company that is a trustee, check whether the trust’s ABN or a scheme’s ARSN applies) and check the supplier’s own registrations: the grantor details, the collateral class (the kind of property covered) and whether a PMSI is stated. Check the registration date against two other dates: when the contract or account terms came into force (for a foreign-law contract, also when the interest first became enforceable in Australia) and, for a PMSI, when the customer obtained possession of the goods. A registration against the wrong details does not survive. Nor does one made too late, unless a court extends the time.
- Check the contract itself: the customer must have signed or accepted the written retention of title terms, and the terms must describe the goods. Otherwise, a registration does not protect them.
- Identify the supplier’s goods in the warehouse. Match invoices, packing lists, batch or serial numbers and photographs to what is in the warehouse, and separate unpaid goods from paid ones. Note which goods have already been sold, mixed into other products or installed.
- Write to the administrator with the contract, the registration and the list of goods. Ask that the goods be held and not sold, and ask for written consent to collect them or for the proceeds to be kept separate. The request alone cannot prevent a sale in the ordinary course of the customer’s business.37 Send English translations of any contracts and invoices written in another language.
- Before the first creditors’ meeting, send details of the debt to the person the meeting notice names, so that the supplier can vote.38
- Move quickly on a late registration, or on a sale the supplier wants to stop. An application to extend the time for a late registration, or to stop a sale, is made to the court. An extension can help only a registration made before the appointment.39
- For the next customer, register within 20 business days after the terms are agreed and before the first delivery, against the right details (usually the ACN), as a PMSI, and keep signed or accepted terms that describe the goods.
For a customer that is not paying but has not gone into administration, a separate article explains the route from letter of demand to statutory demand.
Questions
- Can we register on the PPSR now that the administrators have been appointed?
- Registering on the PPSR after the appointment does not help with goods already supplied. An interest that was unperfected at the appointment passed to the customer immediately before the administrator was appointed.
- Does a deed of company arrangement end our claim to the goods?
- A deed of company arrangement usually leaves the claim intact, because a supplier whose interest is perfected can still enforce it. That changes only if the supplier voted for a deed that provides otherwise, or if the court so orders.
- Do we need to lodge a proof of debt in a voluntary administration?
- A supplier can vote at a creditors’ meeting if the administrator has admitted its debt. Otherwise, it lodges particulars of the debt, usually on the administrator’s proof of debt form, with the person presiding at the meeting or the person named in the meeting notice.
- Can the administrator sell our goods?
- The administrator can sell the goods in the ordinary course of the customer’s business, with the supplier’s written consent, or with the court’s leave. A sale of goods subject to a perfected retention of title interest ends that interest, and the administrator must apply the net proceeds in the order the PPSA sets for a secured party.
This article is general information about Australian law as at the date shown above. It is not legal advice and does not take account of your circumstances. Reading it does not create a lawyer–client relationship with SQ Legal. Obtain advice on your own matter before acting. See the terms of use.
Related
- An Australian buyer has not paid. From letter of demand to statutory demand
- Can a Chinese or US money judgment be enforced in Australia?
More on cross-border commercial disputes and debt recovery, or contact SQ Legal about a matter.
Anna Zheng, ‘An Australian customer has gone into administration. Can an overseas supplier get its goods back?’, SQ Legal (Web Page, 16 November 2026) <https://sqlegal.com.au/insights/customer-administration-retention-of-title/>.
You may quote short extracts with attribution and a link to this page. To republish the article in full, write to [email protected]Email[email protected]Open in your default email appGmailOutlook (personal)Outlook (work or school)Or copy the address:[email protected].
Footnotes
-
Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) s 267(1)(a)(ii), (b)(ii), (2) (‘PPSA’); Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 588FL(4)(a) (‘Corporations Act’). ↩
-
PPSA (n 1) s 12(1), (2)(d). ↩
-
Ibid s 21(1)–(2). ↩
-
Ibid ss 20(1)(b)(iii), (2), 21(1). ↩
-
Ibid s 267(1)(a)(ii), (b)(ii), (2); Corporations Act (n 1) s 437A(2) note. ↩
-
PPSA (n 1) s 267(1)(b)(ii); Corporations Act (n 1) ss 435C(1)(a), 513C(b). ↩
-
PPSA (n 1) s 6(1). ↩
-
Ibid ss 235(3), 238(1A), (2), (2A), (3). ↩
-
Ibid s 234(2). ↩
-
Ibid s 10 (definition of ‘goods’). ↩
-
Ibid s 153(1) table item 4; Personal Property Securities Regulations 2010 (Cth) sch 1 cl 2.3 (‘PPS Regulations’). ↩
-
PPSA (n 1) ss 31(1)(a), 32(1), 33(1)–(2), 46(1). ↩
-
Ibid ss 99, 101. ↩
-
Ibid ss 10 (definition of ‘accession to other goods’), 88. ↩
-
Ibid ss 8(1)(j), 10 (definition of ‘fixtures’). ↩
-
PPS Regulations (n 11) sch 1 cl 1.3(1)(a) table items 2–3, cl 1.5(1)(a) table item 2. ↩
-
PPSA (n 1) ss 164(1)(b), 165(b). ↩
-
Re OneSteel Manufacturing Pty Ltd (admins apptd) [2017] NSWSC 21, [1], [4]–[7], [28], [80], [84]–[85] (Brereton J) (‘OneSteel’). ↩
-
Corporations Act (n 1) s 588FL(1)(a)(ii), (2)(a), (b)(i)–(ii), (4)(a), (7). ↩
-
Ibid s 588FL(2)(b)(iii). ↩
-
Ibid ss 58AA(1) (definition of ‘Court’), 588FM(1)–(3). ↩
-
Ibid s 588FL(1)–(2); OneSteel (n 18) [7]–[8], [69]–[70], [74]–[75], [82]. ↩
-
Corporations Act (n 1) s 588FL(2)(b)(ii). ↩
-
PPSA (n 1) s 14(1)(a), (3). ↩
-
Ibid ss 10 (definition of ‘inventory’), 62(1)–(2). ↩
-
Ibid ss 10 (definition of ‘document of title’), 62(3), 65. ↩
-
Ibid s 55(4)–(5). ↩
-
Ibid ss 55(4)–(5), 62(2)–(3), 165(b), 267(2); Corporations Act (n 1) ss 588FL(2)(b)(i)–(iii), (4), 588FM(2). ↩
-
Corporations Act (n 1) s 440B(1)–(2), table items 1, 4. ↩
-
Ibid ss 51F(1), 435B. ↩
-
Ibid s 442C(1)–(2), (8). ↩
-
Ibid s 442C(4)–(6). ↩
-
Ibid ss 442C(7), 442CB(1), 442CC(1A); PPSA (n 1) s 140(2). ↩
-
Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016 (Cth) s 75-85(3) (‘Insolvency Practice Rules’). ↩
-
Corporations Act (n 1) s 439C. ↩
-
Ibid ss 444D(2), (3A), 444F(2). ↩
-
Ibid ss 440B(2)(a), 442C(2)(b), (8). ↩
-
Insolvency Practice Rules (n 34) s 75-85(3). ↩
-
Corporations Act (n 1) ss 442C(4)–(6), 588FL(2)(a), 588FM(1). ↩